The Giants should make one last push for Carlos Beltran
by Troy Nelson, 22gigantes.com
Goodbye Albert. Hello Carlos?
The world champion St. Louis Cardinals, still reeling from the loss of one of the most prolific offensive forces in the team’s storied history, are getting closer to signing another player who can handle the bat pretty well — Carlos Beltran.
And while nobody is going to mistake Beltran for Albert Pujols anytime soon, signing the 34-year old free agent outfielder would at least give St. Louis a fighting chance to defend its title.
Pujols bolted for “greener” pastures last week after signing a 260-godzillion dollar contract with the Angels, leaving a gaping hole in the Redbirds’ lineup.
Enter Beltran, who has been somewhat relegated to bottom-of-the-barrel status (in terms of chops-licking free agents, anyway).
This much is true: The longer Beltran stays out there, the more affordable he becomes.
With the exception of Prince Fielder (who will command a salary big enough to buy off his dad’s attention a thousand times over), all the other star-powered names have been scooped up this winter.
C.J. Wilson has joined Pujols in Los Angeles. The Marlins got busy with Jose Reyes, Heath Bell and Mark Buehrle. Jimmy Rollins just re-signed with the Phillies. The Brewers signed Aramis Ramirez. Michael Cuddyer will suit up for the Rockies.
That just leaves Beltran among the “affordable” pack.
Supposedly, Beltran already has one offer on the table — a $10 million per year deal with a yet-to-be-named team. That team could be the Cards or Blue Jays, or one of two “mystery teams” according to Scott Miller at CBS Sports, who adds that Beltran prefers more than just one year.
It’s difficult to imagine the Giants plunking out $10 million a year at this point. The front office folks have openly declared the shopping spree season over.
CEO Larry Baer told fans last week that the team does not want to risk losing star pitchers Tim Lincecum or Matt Cain to free agency “down the road” because the Giants are strapped with expensive contracts. (Cough. Barry Zito. Cough. Aaron Rowand.)
Forget about Zito for a minute. Imagine if the Giants had not agreed to a fifth year on Rowand’s contract. That’s $12 million right there. That’s Beltran in a San Fran uni.
I can see why ownership might be a little gun shy. Not one, but two albatrossian contracts still on the books will do that to a person.
But my momma always said, “it takes money to make money.” (OK, she actually said, “well I’ll be a dirty, cow-kicking, he-brother” but none of us kids ever figured out what that meant.)
Listen. You hear that? That’s the sound of the Giants out on the precipice. It’s quiet out here. And a little scary too.
There’s no question the Giants are at a critical point here if they want to return to their rally thong glory days.
Yes, we still have Timmy, Matty, MadBum, and Vogey. Buster and Freddy are coming back. Pablo’s poised for another All-Star season.
But there are question marks, too…
- …starting with the two young dudes named Brandon. Neither has proven he can hit in the big leagues.
- For that matter, Aubrey Huff‘s bat is no sure thing either.
- Giants pitching coach Dave Righetti said last week that the toll of 200+ innings per season will eventually catch up to the starters.
- And, as much as I like the Pagan and Melky signings, those two guys could still end up being the 2011 versions of Andres Torres and Cody Ross.
So why not go for it all now? Sign Beltran for two years, $20 million.
The Giants are going to extend Cain to a monstrous deal in the next couple of months, so he’s safe. And Lincecum is still under the team’s control for two more years, so he’s safe too.
Hear me out, Mr. Baer. I’m talking two measly years here. Not five years like Rowand, or seven like Zito.
Sign Beltran for two years, $20 million.
He’s going to be 35 at the start of the season, so anything longer is definitely too risky. Plus, three years (even if it’s an option year) could muddle things up with Timmy and some of the other young players. We don’t want to see Lincecum pull a Pujols, so you need to keep the books clear for 2014. I get that.
But one way the Giants can ensure there’s money on the books in ’14 is by — oh, I don’t know — winning another World Series! Can they do that with the offensive production we saw in 2011? Of course not.
Beltran (.300/.385/.525/.910, 22 HR, 84 RBI in 598 plate appearances last season) has said he would love to come back to San Francisco (and the ball club even did its part in getting him some offensive help in the lineup).
The time is now for the Giants to make one last push for a big bat. The rewards far outweigh the risks in this one.
Carlos Beltran: Two years. $20 million.
Another downtown parade: priceless.